Economic Sanctions and Sovereignty: Balancing Trade Laws and International Norms

سال انتشار: 1404
نوع سند: مقاله ژورنالی
زبان: فارسی
مشاهده: 27

فایل این مقاله در 23 صفحه با فرمت PDF قابل دریافت می باشد

استخراج به نرم افزارهای پژوهشی:

لینک ثابت به این مقاله:

شناسه ملی سند علمی:

JR_IAG-21-0_009

تاریخ نمایه سازی: 26 بهمن 1404

چکیده مقاله:

In recent decades, economic sanctions have become an increasingly preferred instrument of international diplomacy, aiming to enforce global norms without resorting to armed conflict. However, the expanding use of unilateral sanctions—particularly those with extraterritorial reach—has reignited tensions with foundational principles of state sovereignty and international trade law. Despite their growing prevalence, the legal legitimacy of these measures remains contested, with many occupying a gray area in international law. This study addresses the gap in scholarly consensus on the legal and normative status of unilateral sanctions vis-à-vis multilateral regimes. The central objective is to evaluate whether economic sanctions, especially those not authorized by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), are legally compatible with principles of sovereignty, non-intervention, and World Trade Organization (WTO) rules. Employing doctrinal legal research, the article analyzes core instruments like the UN Charter, GATT Article XXI, case law, and academic literature. Key findings reveal that while UNSC-backed sanctions enjoy firm legal standing, unilateral sanctions challenge established norms, often triggering disputes over jurisdiction and extraterritoriality. The study concludes that while sanctions may serve legitimate policy aims, their legal justification must balance sovereignty, proportionality, and global normative commitments to maintain legitimacy within the international legal order.

نویسندگان

Anussha A/P Komarasamy

Faculty of Law, University Kebangsaan, Malaysia.

Dhaifina Hani Mohmad Yusri

Faculty of Law, University Kebangsaan, Malaysia.

Eshraq Mahmood Shukur

College of Law, Al-Bayan University, Iraq.

Ali Hamza Nimrud

College of Law, Al-Mustaqbal University, Iraq.

Mohd Izzat Amsyar Mohd Arif

Faculty of Law, University Kebangsaan, Malaysia.

مراجع و منابع این مقاله:

لیست زیر مراجع و منابع استفاده شده در این مقاله را نمایش می دهد. این مراجع به صورت کاملا ماشینی و بر اساس هوش مصنوعی استخراج شده اند و لذا ممکن است دارای اشکالاتی باشند که به مرور زمان دقت استخراج این محتوا افزایش می یابد. مراجعی که مقالات مربوط به آنها در سیویلیکا نمایه شده و پیدا شده اند، به خود مقاله لینک شده اند :
  • Abdullah, R. K; Daud, S; Abadi, A.M; Althabhawi, N.M; Khadim, ...
  • Althabhawi, N; Hui, C.J; Min, H.M; Xue, L; Bagheri, P; ...
  • Althabhawi, N; Zainol, Z.A. (۲۰۱۴). The patent legal system in ...
  • Azmi, R; Azmy, A.S; Zahir, M.Z.M; Al-Dulaimi, A.H.A. (۲۰۲۳). Veto ...
  • Batinga, J. (۲۰۲۴). Reconciling the global North–South divide on the ...
  • Bhengu, W. (۲۰۱۴). Do economic sanctions go against WTO rules? ...
  • Biersteker, T.J; Eckert, S.E; Tourinho, M. (۲۰۱۶). Targeted Sanctions: The ...
  • Bring, O. (۲۰۰۰). The Westphalian Peace Tradition in International Law: ...
  • Cambridge University Press. (۲۰۰۹). Norms reconstituting interests: global racial equality ...
  • Chatham House. (۲۰۲۳). Reforming UN Sanctions: Due Process and Humanitarian ...
  • De Wet, E. (۲۰۰۵). The Chapter VII Powers of the ...
  • Douhan, A.F. (۲۰۲۰). Report of the Special Rapporteur on the ...
  • Drezner, D.W. (۲۰۱۱). Sanctions sometimes smart: Targeted sanctions in theory ...
  • European Commission. (۲۰۱۸). Protecting EU companies against the effects of ...
  • European Council. (۲۰۱۴). EU restrictive measures in response to the ...
  • European Council. (۲۰۲۲). EU response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/eu-response-ukraine-invasion/ ...
  • European External Action Service. (۲۰۲۴). European Union sanctions. https://www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/european-union-sanctions_en ...
  • Farrall, J.M. (۲۰۰۷). United Nations sanctions and the rule of ...
  • General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (۱۹۴۷) https://www.wto. Org/English /docs_e/legal_e/gatt۴۷_e.htm ...
  • Geranmayeh, E; Lafont Rapnouil, M. (۲۰۱۹). Meeting the challenge of ...
  • Gheyle, N; De Ville, F. (۲۰۱۷). Explaining the post-crisis turn ...
  • Gibson Dunn. (۲۰۲۰). ۲۰۱۹ Year-End Sanctions Update. https://www. Gib- sondunn.com/wp-content/uploads/۲۰۲۰/۰۱/۲۰۱۹-year-end-sanctions-update.pdf ...
  • Guzman, A. (۲۰۲۱). Extraterritoriality and the Limits of Sanctions. Retrieved ...
  • Hendrik Spruyt (۱۹۹۴). The Sovereign State and Its Competitors: An ...
  • Howse, R; Teitel, R. (۲۰۱۰). Beyond compliance: Rethinking why international ...
  • Human Rights Watch. (۲۰۱۹). “Maximum Pressure”: US economic sanctions harm ...
  • Human Rights Watch. (۲۰۲۱). Reflections on apartheid and persecution in ...
  • International Court of Justice. (۱۹۸۶). Military and Paramilitary Activities in ...
  • International Law Commission. (۲۰۱۹). Fifth Report on Peremptory Norms (Jus ...
  • Jaeger, J. (۲۰۲۱). Circumventing sovereignty: Extraterritorial sanctions leveraging the technologies ...
  • Jia, Y. (۲۰۲۳). Global human rights sanctions and state sovereignty: ...
  • Julié, W; Menegon, S; Murgier, A. (۲۰۲۴). United States extraterritoriality: ...
  • Mishra, V. (۲۰۲۴). General Assembly renews long‑standing call for end ...
  • Mitchell, A; Nzelibe, J. (۲۰۰۶). Security exceptions and the WTO: ...
  • Müller, T. (۲۰۲۰). The extraterritorial reach of sanctions: A study ...
  • Opinio Juris. (۲۰۱۹a). Panel Report in Russia – Traffic in ...
  • Opinio Juris. (۲۰۱۹b). WTO and National Security: Russia-Ukraine Transit Case. ...
  • Osiander, A. (۲۰۰۱). Sovereignty, international relations, and the Westphalian myth. ...
  • Othman, M.B. (۲۰۰۰). Remote sensing: Capabilities and legal issues. Journal ...
  • Pirani, S; Naderi, M. (۲۰۲۴). The causes of ineffectiveness of ...
  • Ramalinggam, R; Noh, N.I.M; Dahlan, N.K. (۲۰۱۵). Penggunaan emas dan ...
  • Review of International Studies. (۱۹۹۶). Norms and sanctions: lessons from ...
  • Sefriani, S; Julian, A.R; Monteiro, S. (۲۰۲۴). Shedding light on ...
  • Sthoeger, E. (۲۰۲۴). Article ۱۰۳ of the United Nations Charter: ...
  • Thakur, R. (۲۰۰۶). The United Nations, Peace and Security: From ...
  • U.S. Department of the Treasury. (n.d.). Sanctions programs and country ...
  • United Nations General Assembly. (۲۰۰۰). Resolution A/RES/۵۵/۲۰ – Extraterritorial effects ...
  • United Nations General Assembly. (۲۰۱۹). Resolution A/RES/۷۴/۷ – Necessity of ...
  • United Nations General Assembly. (۱۹۷۰). Declaration on Principles of International ...
  • United Nations General Assembly. (۱۹۷۳). International Convention on the Suppression ...
  • United Nations General Assembly. (۱۹۸۱). Declaration on the Inadmissibility of ...
  • United Nations General Assembly. (۲۰۰۵). ۲۰۰۵ World Summit Outcome, A/RES/۶۰/۱, ...
  • United Nations Security Council. (۲۰۲۲). Resolution ۲۶۶۴ (۲۰۲۲): Humanitarian carve-outs ...
  • United Nations Security Council. (۲۰۰۶). Resolution ۱۶۹۶ (۲۰۰۶). https://undocs.org/S/RES/۱۶۹۶ (۲۰۰۶) ...
  • United Nations Security Council. (۲۰۱۵). Resolution ۲۲۳۱ (۲۰۱۵). https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/content/۲۲۳۱ ...
  • United Nations Security Council. (n.d.). Repertoire of the Practice of ...
  • United Nations. (۱۹۴۵). Charter of the United Nations and Statute ...
  • United Nations. (۲۰۲۳). Subsidiary organs of the United Nations Security ...
  • Whyte, J. (۲۰۲۲). Economic coercion and financial war. Journal of ...
  • World Trade Organization. (۱۹۹۵). Analytical index of the GATT: Article ...
  • World Trade Organization. (۲۰۱۹). Russia – Measures Concerning Traffic in ...
  • Yee, V. V; Sivakumar, S.N; Razali, N.I; Mahpop, A; Suaree, ...
  • نمایش کامل مراجع