There Is No Best Practice: When Evidence-Based Teaching Principles Conflict in EFL Classrooms
سال انتشار: 1405
نوع سند: مقاله کنفرانسی
زبان: انگلیسی
مشاهده: 162
- صدور گواهی نمایه سازی
- من نویسنده این مقاله هستم
استخراج به نرم افزارهای پژوهشی:
شناسه ملی سند علمی:
ICMRE08_014
تاریخ نمایه سازی: 27 مهر 1405
چکیده مقاله:
This review article examines the persistent conflict among evidence-based teaching principles in English as a Foreign Language (EFL) pedagogy, addressing the problem that no single instructional practice, however well supported empirically, has proven universally superior across the diverse cognitive, cultural, and institutional conditions in which language learning occurs. Motivated by the tension between the movement toward evidence-informed pedagogy and the documented failure of any single method to yield consistent outcomes across contexts, the study maps how competing principles – form-focused versus meaning-focused instruction, teacher belief versus classroom practice, and universal pedagogical models versus culturally embedded traditions – coexist and conflict within the same instructional space. Adopting an analytical-review methodology, the study synthesizes empirical, theoretical, and mixed-methods research on postmethod pedagogy, principled eclecticism, focus-on-form instruction, teacher cognition, sociocultural perspectives, and cognitive-psycholinguistic models of second-language memory, drawing these strands into an interpretive framework centred on teachers' sense of pedagogical plausibility and a two-dimensional model of principled eclecticism. The findings indicate that such conflicts are not symptoms of flawed research but structural features of language pedagogy, arising from variation in learners' cognitive profiles, institutional and assessment pressures, sociocultural expectations of the teacher's role, and the differing time-scales over which form- and meaning-focused instruction operate; the recurring gap between teacher belief and classroom practice likewise emerges across diverse settings as a rational adaptation to context rather than a professional failure. The study concludes that the search for a single best practice should be replaced by cultivating teachers' research literacy and principled, context-sensitive eclecticism, in which evidence serves as a flexible starting framework rather than a fixed prescription, and it calls on teacher education programmes to train context-responsive decision-making rather than compliance with any one method.
کلیدواژه ها:
نویسندگان
Hanieh Narouei
B.A. Student in TEFL, Farhangian University, Shahid Bahonar Campus, Kerman, Iran
Hooria Moshki
B.A. Student in TEFL, Farhangian University, Shahid Bahonar Campus, Kerman, Iran
Masoud Bahreyni
Department of English Language Teaching, Farhangian University, Kerman, Iran