Utilizing Virtual Reality in the participatory urban policy-making process: A step toward facilitating effective citizen engagement

سال انتشار: 1404
نوع سند: مقاله ژورنالی
زبان: انگلیسی
مشاهده: 77

فایل این مقاله در 20 صفحه با فرمت PDF قابل دریافت می باشد

استخراج به نرم افزارهای پژوهشی:

لینک ثابت به این مقاله:

شناسه ملی سند علمی:

JR_IJHCUM-10-2_012

تاریخ نمایه سازی: 24 فروردین 1404

چکیده مقاله:

traditional participatory urban processes, effective collaboration among designers, citizens, and urban managers is often hindered by inadequate environmental visualization, inefficient communication tools, and limited appeal. These challenges, particularly related to time, cost, and the difficulty of attracting diverse participants, have prompted researchers to explore alternative tools and technologies to enhance citizen involvement. Virtual Reality modeling has emerged as a promising technology for urban design, planning, and management, offering improved ways to visualize spaces, develop creative ideas, and support the realization of urban policies. This research is qualitative and developmental in purpose, and it is classified as a review study with an interpretive perspective. The methods employed include documentary analysis and case studies, with data collected from documents, library resources, and relevant articles in this field. The study draws on theoretical frameworks such as Arnstein’s Ladder of Citizen Participation and Healey’s Collaborative Planning Theory to examine Virtual Reality's potential in participatory processes. The study addresses the limitations of traditional participatory methods, highlighting how Virtual Reality technology can facilitate more accessible, inclusive, and efficient urban policymaking processes. Despite technological limitations, physical and psychological constraints, ethical concerns, and issues related to privacy and legal matters, the findings indicate that virtual Reality offers significant potential in participatory urban processes. By providing immersive simulations, virtual Reality can improve transparency, enhance stakeholder collaboration, and facilitate informed decision-making in urban planning. The technology's ability to engage diverse demographic groups, particularly those reluctant to engage in traditional methods, shows promise for making urban policy discussions more interactive and understandable. Virtual Reality presents a valuable tool for overcoming the limitations of conventional participatory processes and holds promise for enhancing urban policymaking. The study identifies several avenues for future exploration, including improving accessibility, addressing ethical concerns, and developing hybrid engagement models that integrate Virtual reality with traditional methods. Empirical evaluations of Virtual Reality’s impact on decision-making and stakeholder engagement are also recommended to optimize its application in urban governance. Its potential benefits make it an important area for further exploration of urban planning and participatory governance.

نویسندگان

A. Shakibamanesh

Department of Urban Planning and Design, School of Architecture and Urban Studies, Iran University of Art, Tehran, Iran.

M. Ghorbanian

Department of Landscape Architecture, School of Architecture and Environmental Design, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, Iran.

S. Izadi

Department of Urban Planning and Design, School of Architecture and Urban Studies, Iran University of Art, Tehran, Iran.

A. Riahi

Department of Urban Planning and Design, School of Architecture and Urban Studies, Iran University of Art, Tehran, Iran.

P. Zeifodini

Department of Urban Planning and Design, School of Architecture and Urban Studies, Iran University of Art, Tehran, Iran.

مراجع و منابع این مقاله:

لیست زیر مراجع و منابع استفاده شده در این مقاله را نمایش می دهد. این مراجع به صورت کاملا ماشینی و بر اساس هوش مصنوعی استخراج شده اند و لذا ممکن است دارای اشکالاتی باشند که به مرور زمان دقت استخراج این محتوا افزایش می یابد. مراجعی که مقالات مربوط به آنها در سیویلیکا نمایه شده و پیدا شده اند، به خود مقاله لینک شده اند :
  • Agudelo-Vélez, A.; Sarmiento-Ordosgoitia, I.; Córdoba-Maquilón, J. (۲۰۲۱). Virtual reality as ...
  • Al Shawabkeh, R.; Arar, M. (۲۰۲۴). The role of virtual ...
  • Al-Kodmany, K. (۲۰۲۰). Tall buildings and the city: Improving the ...
  • Al-Kodmany, K. (۲۰۰۲). Visualization tools and methods in community planning: ...
  • The effect of digital leadership on the performance of businesses: the mediating role of organizational entrepreneurship [مقاله ژورنالی]
  • Araiza-Alba, P.; Keane, T.; Chen, W. S.; Kaufman, J. (۲۰۲۱). ...
  • Bakhanova, E.; Garcia, J. A.; Raffe, W. L.; Voinov, A. ...
  • Barki, H.; Hartwick, J. (۱۹۸۹). Rethinking the concept of user ...
  • Baniasadi, T.; Niakan Kalhori, S. R.; Ayyoubzadeh, S. M.; Zakerabasali, ...
  • Basu, A. (۲۰۱۹). A brief chronology of Virtual Reality. Preprint ...
  • Batty, M. (۲۰۱۳). Big data, smart cities, and city planning. ...
  • Boertien, R. (۲۰۲۱). Immersive Virtual Reality, a participatory-enhancing tool for ...
  • Boos, Bolton, T.; Dargahi, T.; Belguith, S.; Al-Rakhami, M. S.; ...
  • Brilakis, I.; Fischer, H.; Pan, Y.; Borrmann, A.; Mayer, H.-G.; ...
  • Burdea, G.; Coiffet, P. (۱۹۹۴). Virtual Reality Technology. John Wiley ...
  • Caldarola, E. G.; Rinaldi, A. M. (۲۰۱۷). Big data visualization ...
  • Castelnovo, W.; Misuraca, G.; Savoldelli, A. (۲۰۱۶). Smart cities governance: ...
  • Ceconello, M.; Spallazzo, D. (۲۰۰۸, October). Virtual reality for enhanced ...
  • Checa, D.; Bustillo, A. (۲۰۲۰). A review of immersive virtual ...
  • Clarke, E. (۲۰۲۱). Virtual reality simulation—the future of orthopedic training? ...
  • Connor, D. M. (۱۹۸۸). A new ladder of citizen participation. ...
  • Cosgrave, E.; Tryfonas, T.; Crick, T. (۲۰۱۴). The smart city ...
  • Cruz-Neira, C.; Sandin, D. J.; DeFanti, T. A. (۱۹۹۳). Surround-screen ...
  • Delgado, J. M. D.; Oyedele, L.; Demian, P.; Beach, T. ...
  • Dembski, F.; Wössner, U.; Letzgus, M.; Ruddat, M.; Yamu, C. ...
  • Deterding, S.; Sicart, M.; Nacke, L.; O'Hara, K.; Dixon, D. ...
  • Dyer, M.; Corsini, F.; Certomà, C. (۲۰۱۷). Making urban design ...
  • Ehab, A.; Heath, T.; Burnett, G. (۲۰۲۳, July). Virtual Reality ...
  • El Araby, M. (۲۰۰۲, February). Possibilities and constraints of using ...
  • Falanga, R. (۲۰۲۰). Participatory design: participatory urban management. In Sustainable ...
  • Fares, F.; Taha, D. S.; Sayad, Z. T. E. (۲۰۱۸). ...
  • Feeney, M. K.; Welch, E. W. (۲۰۱۲). Electronic participation technologies ...
  • Fernández, R. P.; Alonso, V. (۲۰۱۵). Virtual Reality in a ...
  • Fraser, M.; Bjornsson, H. (۲۰۰۴). Real-time digital modeling in design ...
  • Gandhi, R. D.; Patel, D. S. (۲۰۱۸). Virtual reality–opportunities and ...
  • García, M.; Eizaguirre, S.; & Pradel, M. (۲۰۱۵). Social innovation ...
  • Getso, M. M. A.; Bakon, K. A. (۲۰۱۷). Virtual reality ...
  • Greenhalgh, T.; Robert, G.; Macfarlane, F.; Bate, P.; Kyriakidou, O. ...
  • Halvorsen, K. E. (۲۰۰۳). Assessing the effects of public participation. ...
  • Harris, T.; Weiner, D. (۱۹۹۸). Empowerment, marginalization, and" community-integrated" GIS. ...
  • Hassan, L.; Hamari, J. (۲۰۲۰). Gameful civic engagement: A review ...
  • Healey, P. (۲۰۲۰). Collaborative planning: Shaping places in fragmented societies. ...
  • Hidayah, N.; Meidiana, C.; Firdausiyah, N.; Ghosh, R. K.; Amalia, ...
  • Hirzle, T. (۲۰۲۳). Digital Eye Strain in Virtual Reality Head-Mounted ...
  • Ismail, A. W.; Sunar, M. S. (۲۰۰۹). Collaborative augmented reality: ...
  • Jamei, E.; Mortimer, M.; Seyedmahmoudian, M.; Horan, B.; Stojcevski, A. ...
  • Jiang, L.; Masullo, M.; Maffei, L.; Meng, F.; Vorländer, M. ...
  • Johansen, A. G.; Pedersen, C. B. (۲۰۱۹). Gamified participation: Challenging ...
  • Kaddoura, S.; Al Husseiny, F. (۲۰۲۳). The rising trend of ...
  • Kaimara, P.; Oikonomou, A.; Deliyannis, I. (۲۰۲۲). Could virtual reality ...
  • Kamińska, D.; Sapiński, T.; Wiak, S.; Tikk, T.; Haamer, R. ...
  • Kaplan, A. D.; Cruit, J.; Endsley, M.; Beers, S. M.; ...
  • Kim, J.; Kim, S. (۲۰۱۹). Finding the optimal D/H ratio ...
  • Kim, Y. M.; Rhiu, I.; Yun, M. H. (۲۰۲۰). A ...
  • Kitson, J.; Leiva, M.; Christman, Z.; Dalton, P. (۲۰۱۹). Evaluating ...
  • Korkut, E. H.; Surer, E. (۲۰۲۳). Visualization in virtual reality: ...
  • Kulal, S.; Li, Z.; Tian, X. (۲۰۲۲). Security and privacy ...
  • Kuna, P.; Hašková, A.; Borza, Ľ. (۲۰۲۳). Creation of virtual ...
  • Lanier, J. (۲۰۱۷). Dawn of the New Everything: Encounters with ...
  • Lele, A. (۲۰۱۳). Virtual reality and its military utility. J. ...
  • Li, H.; Zhang, J.; Xia, L.; Song, W.; Bode, N. ...
  • Lippman, A. (۱۹۸۰). Movie-maps: An application of the optical videodisc ...
  • Lironi, E. (۲۰۱۶). Potential and Challenges of E-participation in the ...
  • Liu, X. (۲۰۲۰). Three-dimensional visualized urban landscape planning and design ...
  • Meenar, M.; Kitson, J. (۲۰۲۰). Using multi-sensory and multi-dimensional immersive ...
  • Mueller, J.; Lu, H.; Chirkin, A.; Klein, B.; Schmitt, G. ...
  • Nesti, G. (۲۰۲۰). Partnerships for innovation: The case of the ...
  • Nochta, T.; Wan, L.; Schooling, J. M.; Parlikad, A. K. ...
  • Oksman,V.; Väätänen, A.; Ylikauppila, M. (۲۰۱۴). Future Illustrative and Participative ...
  • Pallavicini, F.; Argenton, L.; Toniazzi, N.; Aceti, L.; Mantovani, F. ...
  • Pimentel, D.; Kalyanaraman, S. (۲۰۲۲). The effects of embodying wildlife ...
  • Portman, M. E., Natapov, A., & Fisher-Gewirtzman, D. (۲۰۱۵). To ...
  • Rheingold, H. (۱۹۹۱). Virtual Reality. Summit Books: ۱–۴۱۵ (۴۱۶ pages) ...
  • Rogers, S. L.; Broadbent, R.; Brown, J.; Fraser, A.; Speelman, ...
  • Saeed, Z. O.; Mancini, F.; Glusac, T.; Izadpanahi, P. (۲۰۲۲). ...
  • Sagnier, C.; Loup-Escande, E.; Valléry, G. (۲۰۲۰). Effects of gender ...
  • Sarjakoski, T. (۱۹۹۸). Networked GIS for public participation—emphasis on utilizing ...
  • Savoldelli, A.; Codagnone, C.; Misuraca, G. (۲۰۱۴). Understanding the e-government ...
  • Scerri, K.; Attard, M. (۲۰۲۳). People as planners: Stakeholder participation ...
  • Schively, C. (۲۰۰۷). A quantitative analysis of consensus building in ...
  • Schrom-Feiertag, H.; Stubenschrott, M.; Regal, G., Matyus, T.; Seer, S. ...
  • Schrotter, G.; Hürzeler, C. (۲۰۲۰). The digital twin of the ...
  • Scrivner, O.; Madewell, J.; Buckley, C.; Perez, N. (۲۰۱۹). Best ...
  • Shahat, E.; Hyun, C. T.; Yeom, C. (۲۰۲۱). City digital ...
  • Shakeri, M. (۲۰۱۷). The use of digital games in participatory ...
  • Sherman, W. R.; Craig, A. B. (۲۰۰۳). Understanding Virtual Reality: ...
  • Smith, L.; Lyons, F.; Bridges, B.; & Casey, R. (۲۰۲۲, ...
  • Springs, D. (۲۰۲۴). Elements of Smart Leadership Approaches for Smart ...
  • Stanberry, B. (۲۰۰۱). Legal ethical and risk issues in telemedicine. ...
  • Stanney, K.; Fidopiastis, C.; Foster, L. (۲۰۲۰). Virtual reality is ...
  • Stauskis, G. (۲۰۱۴). Development of methods and practices of virtual ...
  • Stern, E.; Amir, I. (۲۰۰۶). "Benefits of public participation as ...
  • Stern, E.; Gudes, O.; Svoray, T. (۲۰۰۹). Web-based and traditional ...
  • Sutherland, I. E. (۱۹۶۵). The Ultimate Display. Proceedings of the ...
  • Thiel, S. K. (۲۰۱۷). Let’s play Urban Planner: the use ...
  • C.; Reichenbacher, T.; Kiefer, P.; Sailer, C. (۲۰۲۳). An augmented ...
  • Van Dessel, A. (۲۰۱۹). The Use of Virtual Reality in ...
  • Van Leeuwen, J. P.; Hermans, K.; Jylhä, A.; Quanjer, A. ...
  • Wang, Y.; Lin, Y. S. (۲۰۲۳). Public participation in urban ...
  • Weil, M. (۲۰۱۴). Community practice: Conceptual models. Routledge: ۱–۳۱ (۳۱ ...
  • Weinstock, M. (۲۰۱۳). E-Participation–New opportunities for citizen participation in urban ...
  • Weiner, D.; Harris, T. M.; Craig, W. J. (۲۰۰۲). Community ...
  • Whyte, J.; Nikolić, D. (۲۰۱۸). Virtual Reality and the Built ...
  • Wohlgenannt, I.; Simons, A.; Stieglitz, S. (۲۰۲۰). Virtual reality. (BISE)., ...
  • Won, M.; Ungu, D. A. K.; Matovu, H.; Treagust, D. ...
  • Wu, B.; Yu, X.; Gu, X. (۲۰۲۰). Effectiveness of immersive ...
  • Xiang, R. (۲۰۲۴). Enhancing Democratic Governance: The Crucial Role of ...
  • Xu, S. (۲۰۲۱). Three‐Dimensional Visualization Algorithm Simulation of Construction Management ...
  • Yamu, C.; Poplin, A.; Devisch, O.; De Roo, G. (۲۰۱۷). ...
  • نمایش کامل مراجع